Upper Crust Pizza in Maratdon

First time eating at this gem. Amazing appetizers and pizza! The service was great as well. Very friendly folks. Definitely will be back next time we’re in Marathon.

Nice local Italian restaurant and pizza place.

Great pizza reasonably priced with good service.

Best pizza ever!!....Friendly, courteous staff..Smiling faces greeted us the minute we walked in the door....Thank you Upper Crustfor a most excellent experience!

I believe this has the best Key Lime Pie in Marathon Florida 😍

Pizza is good. Customer service terrible.

Wow, just wow. Haven’t had an amazing pizza like this in a very long time, maybe it’s even the best I’ve had!

Fantastic pizza! Wanted a quick dinner on our last night on vacation, was very impressed with the pizza we picked up. Definitely recommend the white pizza, had a nice brown crust.

While I was in Publix I asked someone if there was any good pizza places nearby , she told me to go to Papa John's, no thanks ! Decided to give upper crust a try and just kept my expectations low. I was blown away by how good their pizza was. It's kind of like a pan pizza but they keep the crust thin and crispy , toppings were great. I'll come back for sure.

We are from Indiana and this is probably the best pizza we ever had. We started out with the spinach dip, which was delicious and we polished off pretty quickly. And then after a few pieces of pizza in mind, the whole thing vanished before our eyes. Best pizza ever!

Everything I'm the service to the food was out of this world. It's been two years since I was down here and the food is still as great as it was that. Nice job upper Crest

What an amazing experience!!! The food was incredible and the owners are so special!! I can’t say enough great things!! You must give a try!!!

Delicious food, best prices for the quality in all of the Keys that I have been to so far! You MUST go here if you Love pizza. It brings it to a fine craft here, Seriously the first time I’ve EVER eaten pizza with a fork and knife. It was THAT nice. Also extremely clean with phenomenal customer service. Thank you and Joseph and I will be back for more soon!!

It was a hot day and was looking for a cool place to rest my feet while having some lunch. The unusually decor intrigued me so we stayed, the food was good but the air conditioning was pretty much non existent. I would go again in the winter.

Pizza was good, friendly service. Open late during weekdays !

Absolutely amazing pizza! Ask for their homemade jalapeno pepper jelly, so good.

Very good pizza. Thinner crusted, dough is made fresh daily. Good amount of cheese. We had Italian sausage and mushroom. The restaurant was very clean and inviting. Nice little pizza joint, would return for sure.

The food was amazing and the people are so nice! Mixed with the most amazing atmosphere this place is a must.

Great Pizza! Some of the best pizza we have ever had. Very fresh tasting and the desserts are amazing. Highly recommend!!!

The pizza and pasta we ordered were fantastic and delicious, service was super friendly and speedy. Upper crust in Marathon Key was one of the cleanest restaurants we visited. If you’re craving some pizza or garlic something you won’t be disappointed.

My family and I just stopped in there for a nice casual dinner after skipping the steak and seafood place next door. The white pizza was excellent, homemade meatballs were excellent (my two girls ate these up fast!!), the spaghetti with marinara sauce was great and the service was very nice. They definitely know all the local folks.

The food was really good! Artichokes and bbq pizza was amazing!

Delicious, best pizza around for sure. Definitely order the garlic bread!!

The food salad pizza and dessert and service was very good would go again when in town

Awesome pizza and service, best thin crust pizza I've had since I left NY 10 years ago..I would recommend this restaurant over any of the places I've been since I arrived here. Owners are attentive and the quality of the food is excellent, including the greens and toppings on the salads. Make sure you stop by to see them..

Great service, excellent food and a wonderful overall experience. The staff all went above and beyond to make it a great meal. Wonderful family atmosphere. If this were closer to home it would be a weekly spot for us. Some of the best pizza we have had.

Must try the wings. Mozzarella sticks and pizza were great, too! Had deluxe, like a Supreme, very good.

Friendly service and delicious pizza.

Great food. Owner operated.. Nice people and service..

The best pizza in Marathon. Great atmosphere and friendly staff.

Pepperoni pizza was good but we didn’t love the garlic bread. Would order pizza from here again.

Pizza was good but very skimpy on the ingredients and the crust could have been baked more, for the price you pay the pizza should have been loaded. The staff was nice just not very talkative? Would have given more stars if there would have been more of the ingredients on the pizza and the crust more crispy.

Fresh pie with some amazing apps! We had the roasted artichoke hearts, they were delish!

The pizza was delicious.

We have to stop here whenever we're down here. The staff is very friendly and the pizza is great!!!

I come down to Marathon 3-4 times a year and have never eaten at Upper Crust until tonight. I sure have been missing out. I love finding local pizza places and I think this one might just be one of my all time favorites! I highly recommend this pizza and can't wait to return. I also heard someone there say it has the best lasagna. I can't directly speak to that but if it's anything like their pizza, I'm sure it is amazing.

The food was great but.. we were a party of 6 ... 2 checks and they added in a 20% tip without mentioning it... didn't notice anything posted anywhere. There was only one other table of occupied. The proprietor that waited on us seemed mildly annoyed everytime we asked for anything.

Very good pizza we had: pineapple, sliced tomatoes, ham, mushrooms, anchovies (on the side), and extra cheese. It tasted like brick-oven baked.

Great pizza's! Friendly staff and reasonable prices. Would recommend.

Surprisingly very good pizza. Both my wife and I were happily impressed with the quality of the flavors from both of our respective orders. Small hiccup with miscommunication regarding some pizza toppings, but overall a great, pleasant, & tasty experience! Will definitely come again!

Good pizza, very friendly staff.

Salad and pizza was good. Family run, good service.

Great little restaurant with friendly staff and quick service. The pizza was fantastic!

Great pizza and nice staff. A bit thin but taste was great

This pizza place must be fantastic, because, even though they are open until 9pm, they won't serve you after 8:40pm. So if you are planning to go here go early or your money is no good. I personally rather support a small business who appreciates it's customers.

Great food!

Great! On vacation from GA and found this place with a Google search, glad we did. Pizza was excellent (kind of like a mellow mushroom pizza) and the wings where better then taco mac. (if you have ever been to GA then you know TM has the best wings).

Pizza was excellent great crust and friendly service

The pizza is amazing and the owners are so nice . I will definitely come back. Best pizza I have had in Florida . Very clean

Last night in Marathon and the kids wanted pizza. Of the three to choose from the cabin was out for sure. We decided on this place and I’m glad we did. It’s family operated. Mom and Dad in the front and the kid cooks. Great service and the pizza was great also!